By Ashleigh Francis, Family Solicitor, Laker Legal
Ashleigh Francis is a family solicitor at Laker Legal, advising clients on divorce, financial arrangements and children matters across England and Wales.
An increasing number of people now deal with their own divorce through the online court service. The process is generally straightforward and relatively inexpensive where the sole objective is to bring the marriage legally to an end.
Difficulties often arise, however, when separating couples attempt to deal with their financial arrangements without obtaining legal advice. Clients frequently arrive with what they believe to be a concluded agreement—sometimes recorded in a typed document, an exchange of emails or even a short series of text messages. The explanation is usually the same: “We have agreed everything. We just need a solicitor to make it official.”
That approach is understandable. Most people want to keep costs proportionate and avoid unnecessary conflict. However, an informal agreement may not be legally binding, may omit important assets or claims, or may contain arrangements that cannot be implemented in practice. Correcting those problems later can be substantially more expensive than obtaining appropriate advice at the outset.
Does a divorce settle your finances?
The divorce process brings the marriage to an end. It does not, by itself, determine how the parties’ property, savings, pensions, income or liabilities should be dealt with.
Unless the Family Court makes a financial order, one or both parties may retain the right to bring financial claims against the other. Depending on the circumstances, those claims may include claims for:
- the transfer or sale of property;
- lump-sum payments;
- spousal maintenance;
- pension sharing or pension attachment; and
- other financial provision permitted by law.
Certain claims can remain open after the final divorce order has been made. There have been reported cases in which financial claims were pursued many years after separation, particularly where no clean-break order had been obtained.
An agreement reached privately between spouses—even one recorded clearly in writing—is therefore not the same as a binding court order.
Will a judge approve your consent order?
To make a financial agreement binding, its terms will usually need to be incorporated into a draft consent order and submitted to the Family Court for approval. The parties must also provide the court with prescribed financial information summarising their respective circumstances.
A judge does not simply “rubber-stamp” the agreement. The court must consider whether the proposed order is fair and appropriate in light of the statutory factors, including the parties’ resources, needs, ages, earning capacities, standard of living during the marriage, any disabilities and their responsibilities towards dependent children.
The judge may raise questions, request further information, require amendments or list the matter for a hearing. In some cases, the court may decline to approve the proposed order. This is more likely where:
- the proposed division appears substantially one-sided;
- there is inadequate information about pensions, property or other assets;
- the order does not appear to meet one party’s housing or income needs;
- the arrangements concerning a former matrimonial home are unclear or impractical;
- the financial information supplied to the court is incomplete; or
- the drafting does not accurately reflect what the parties intend.
At that stage, a couple may have waited several weeks only to discover that the agreement cannot be approved in its existing form. They may then require legal advice in circumstances where trust has deteriorated and one party is less willing to compromise.
Common problems with DIY divorce financial agreements
The following issues arise regularly.
1. Inadequate financial disclosure
A fair and reliable agreement ordinarily requires both parties to provide full and frank disclosure of their financial circumstances. This includes income, property, savings, investments, pensions, liabilities, business interests and any other relevant resources.
If an asset is discovered later, the agreement may be challenged. A failure to investigate the financial position properly may also result in one party accepting materially less than they would otherwise have received.
2. Pensions being overlooked or undervalued
An agreement that each party will retain their own pension may appear straightforward, but it is not necessarily fair. Pension benefits can be among the most valuable matrimonial assets and may exceed the net value of the family home.
Two pensions with apparently similar fund values may provide very different retirement benefits. Defined-benefit or final-salary schemes, public-sector pensions and pensions already in payment can require specialist analysis. In suitable cases, advice from a pensions expert or actuary may be necessary.
3. A property arrangement that cannot be implemented
A common proposal is that one party will retain the family home and “take over the mortgage”. That arrangement depends on the mortgage lender agreeing to release the other party from the mortgage obligations.
The Family Court cannot ordinarily compel a commercial lender to transfer a mortgage into one person’s sole name. If the lender refuses, both parties may remain legally responsible for the borrowing, even if only one of them continues to live at the property and make the monthly payments.
The order should address what will happen if a release from the mortgage cannot be obtained, including whether the property must be sold and within what timeframe.
4. No effective clean break
A clean-break order dismisses specified financial claims and is intended to prevent either party from pursuing those claims in the future. Without suitable dismissal provisions, claims for capital, property, pensions or maintenance may remain open.
That can create significant uncertainty, particularly if one party’s financial position later improves or the other party’s circumstances deteriorate.
5. Drafting that cannot be enforced or implemented
A financial order must be drafted with sufficient precision to be enforceable. Ambiguous wording about the sale of a property, responsibility for outgoings or payment deadlines may create further disputes.
Pension sharing requires the correct order and pension sharing annex. The pension provider must also be given the information and documents required to implement the order. If the drafting or accompanying paperwork is defective, the scheme may be unable to act.
6. An agreement that is materially unfair
Some people accept substantially less than their reasonable entitlement because they want the separation to end quickly, feel under pressure or do not understand the long-term consequences.
Although compromise is an important part of reaching an agreement, each party should understand the effect of the proposed terms before committing to them.
Why a DIY settlement may ultimately cost more
Problems with informal agreements often emerge at the least convenient stage. The court may raise questions about the proposed consent order, a mortgage lender may refuse to release one party, a pension provider may reject the paperwork, or a previously undisclosed asset may come to light.
Unravelling a defective agreement or returning to court to correct an inadequate order will usually cost more than obtaining focused advice before the terms are finalised. Some decisions may also be difficult—or, in certain circumstances, impossible—to reverse once an order has been approved and implemented.
How a solicitor turns your agreement into a consent order
Reaching an agreement is a positive step. It does not necessarily mean that negotiations must begin again or that the matter needs to become contentious.
A family solicitor can:
- review the parties’ financial disclosure and identify missing information;
- check that the agreement addresses all relevant assets, liabilities and income;
- consider whether pensions require further investigation or expert evidence;
- advise whether the proposed outcome falls within a reasonable range;
- assess whether arrangements involving property or mortgages are workable;
- ensure that appropriate clean-break provisions are included;
- draft a clear and enforceable consent order;
- prepare the accompanying financial statement; and
- deal with any questions raised by the court.
In many cases, this work can be completed efficiently, with the parties’ existing agreement remaining the starting point.
The bottom line
Handling the administrative divorce process personally can reduce legal costs. Attempting to resolve the financial consequences of divorce without appropriate advice may not.
Obtaining advice before signing or implementing an agreement is generally more cost-effective than correcting an incomplete, unfair or unworkable arrangement later.
If you have reached a financial agreement and would like it reviewed or converted into a binding court order, contact Laker Legal’s family team for a no-obligation quotation. We act for clients across England and Wales, with face-to-face appointments available in the North West.
Frequently asked questions
Is a divorce financial agreement legally binding?
Not on its own. An agreement between spouses, even one in writing, only becomes binding once a judge approves it as a consent order.
Do I need a solicitor to get a consent order?
You are not legally required to use one. But the order must be drafted precisely, supported by the right financial information and approved by a judge, and mistakes can be costly to correct later.
Can my ex make a financial claim years after our divorce?
Possibly. Without a clean-break order dismissing those claims, financial claims can remain open after the final divorce order.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The appropriate approach will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case.
